Guardian Unlimited
Sign in Register 
Go to:  
Guardian Unlimited ArtsArts
Home News Friday Review Regulars Critics Pick of the week Special reports Film Books
Reviews Art Classical Dance Jazz Rock and pop Theatre CDs Help

Keynotes
 
Archive
All articles in this series



 Search this site
 
 All stories
 Reviews only

Recent articles
London Community Gospel Choir Live at Abbey Road CD and DVD

The Police - Every Breath You Take DVD

Moonlight Mile

Schoenberg: Erwartung

John Cage: Sonatas and Interludes

Richard Strauss: Four Last Songs

Mahler: Kindertontenlieder

Belioz: Harold in Italy

Stravinsky: Les Noces

Ravel: Gaspard de la Nuit

Elgar: Allegro for Strings

Britten: Billy Budd

Building a classical library

Smetana: The Bartered Bride

Tim Ashley
Friday May 5, 2000
The Guardian


Premiered in 1866, The Bartered Bride put Czech music on the map. There's been a tendency, however, to misinterpret it - performances that ignore its dark undertow go wide of the mark.

The Czech language, too, has proved a barrier to many singers, so most opera houses gave the work in German. Such was the case at Covent Garden in 1939, in a recording conducted with elan by Thomas Beecham with Richard Tauber's Jenik facing the dramatic Marenka of Hilde Konetzni. Rudolf Kempe's thoughtful version (EMI) pits Pilar Lorengar and Fritz Wunderlich against the imposing Kecal of Gottlob Frick; Jaroslav Krombhoic (RCA) drives the piece too hard.

You really need to hear it in Czech, however, which means turning to Supraphon. Their best version is the most recent. It features the astonishing Gabriela Benackova as a lyrical, vulnerable Marenka. Peter Dvorsky is an outstanding Jenik, while Richard Novak's Kecal is subtler and more humane than most. Zdenek Kosler, conducting the Czech Philharmonic, gets the score's tricky emotional balance just right.

Key Recording: Zdenek Kosler Supraphon 10 3511-2 (two CDs).


UP

Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2003